Table of Contents

Communication Protocol: SPI vs I2C

In today’s faster internet system, efficient data communication is crucial to system performance. Two major communication protocols are used in electronics today: SPI vs I2C. Both have unique features and applications. Thus, in this article, you will learn the difference between SPI vs I2C, and the things to consider while selecting the right protocol for your project.

What is SPI Protocol in Electronics?

SPI Protocol

Serial Peripheral Interface (SPI) is one of the most popular and standard electronic communication interfaces. It mainly facilitates high-speed data exchange between the microcontroller and peripheral devices, which include various sensors, A/D converters, LCDs, memory devices, and more. 

If you check more on SPI, it is also known as serial communication protocol, as it uses the clock signal to synchronize the data transfer between the devices. Motorola, first developed this simple and effective protocol, which was later widely adopted in various applications in the electronics domain.  

The four-wire SPI communication protocol operates in master and slave architecture. The master device of SPI controls the communication and gives commands to the slave’s devices that respond to the master’s command. The four wires of the SPI are as follows:

  • MOSI (Master Out Slave In)—It carries the data transmitted or sent by master devices to the slave devices, like the communication from the microcontroller to the sensor devices. 
  • MISO (Master In Slave Out): It carries data sent from the slave device to the master, such as data from sensors to microcontrollers. 
  • SCK (Serial Clock): It generates the clock signal that synchronizes the data transmission. 
  • SS (Slave Select): It helps to select the slave’s device for communication. The active low slave refers to the low voltage level.

What is the I2C Protocol in Electronics?

I2C Protocol

Inter-Integrated Circuit  (I2C) protocol is the next data communication protocol in electronics. Generally, this protocol allows the multiple integrated circuits to communicate and transfer data with each other in a short distance. It was designed and developed by Philips Semiconductor and is now the standard protocol in the industry. I2C is popular among microcontroller-based projects. 

I2C is also known as a synchronous, multi-master, and multi-slave communication protocol in electronics. 

It uses two lines, also known as bidirectional lines:

  • SDA(Serial Data Line): It carries the data.
  • SCL(Serial Clock Line): It carries the clock signal.

In I2C communication, the master device controls the clock link and initiates communication with the slave device. Since the I2C protocol has multiple masters and multiple slave devices, it uses the unique address to identify and communicate with the specific slaves. 

The address bits are sent by master devices, and it is a 7-10 bit long address followed by the read/write bit.

Then, the master and slave exchange the data in 8-bit frames, which is acknowledged by the ACK (acknowledge bit).

The master generates a stop condition by transitioning SDA from low to high while SCL is high, signaling the end of communication.

SPI vs I2C: Detailed Comparison

SPI vs I2C

When selecting between SPI and I2C, it’s crucial to understand the major differences between your electronic system. Let’s check out some of the major differences between SPI vs I2C below:

Speed and Data Rate

SPI

SPI can achieve higher data rates than I2C. Depending on the hardware and project requirements, it can achieve a speed of 100Mbps or more. 

SPI supports full duplex communication and allows simultaneous data transmission and reception. It further enhances the effective data rates.

I2C

I2C has standard data rates of 100 kbps to 3.4 Mbps (standard to high-speed mode). 

I2C is half-duplex, so data can only be transmitted or received at one time but not simultaneously. This can limit the effective speed.

Power Consumption

SPI

SPI consumes more power due to the need for higher data rates and more pins. Besides, it has a continuous clock signal, which can contribute to higher power usage. 

However, the SPI protocol has a sleep mode that can help maintain low power modes when the devices are not communicating actively. 

 

I2C

I2C uses less power than SPI since it has fewer lines and lower speed. Besides, the clock signal is not continuous, which is also the reason for consuming less power in the I2C protocol. 

Thus, this is advantageous in the case of applications that use battery-operated devices, and power efficiency is critical. 

Complexity and Scalability

SPI

SPI has four lines, which increases the number of pins required in a microcontroller. This increases the complexity of the controller system’s PCB design. 

Each additional slave device requires a separate slave select line from the master, which can limit the number of devices that can be easily connected.

 

I2C

I2C uses only SDA and SCL, simplifying the wiring and reducing the number of pins required in a microcontroller system. 

 

I2C makes it simple to expand and add more devices without adding more lines by supporting multiple devices (both masters and slaves) on the same bus with distinct addresses.

Bus Management and Error Handling

SPI

SPI lacks error-checking mechanisms like checksums and parity bits. Thus, error handling is managed by the application layer. 

It has a simple bus management system with the master controlling the slave for clock and communication signals. 

 

I2C

I2C allows for error detection and handling as it has an acknowledgment mechanism after each data transfer. 

The bus management of I2C is more complex because of clock stretching and multi-master and multi-slave devices. Although the bus mechanism of I2C is smooth, it adds complexity to the system. 

Application and Use Cases: SPI vs I2C

Selecting the right communication protocol can impact the efficiency and performance of the circuit. Let’s check out some use cases of communication protocols below:

When to use SPI?

Applications requiring real-time performance and high-speed data transfer are best suited for SPI. Because of its capacity to reach data rates of up to 100 Mbps or higher, it is appropriate in scenarios where every microsecond matters.

Use cases

  • Memory Chops
  • Sensors
  • Networking

When to use I2C?

I2C is also known as a low-speed and low-power application. It is applicable in areas that don’t require high-speed data transfer and where power efficiency is also not important. 

I2C’s simplicity and low power consumption make it an excellent choice for battery-operated and low-power devices.

Use Cases

    • Temperature Sensors- It is commonly used to interface with the temperature sensors as it dont need to send the large data quickly.
    • ADC(Analog to Digital): Many ADCs use I2C to send the digital data into the microcontrollers. This is because it doesn’t require the conversion speed. 
    • Simple Peripherals- Devices like small displays, GPIO, and real-time clocks use I2C.

Conclusion

Thus, the selection between SPI vs I2C depends on a project’s specific requirements: power consumption, data rate, scalability, and complexity. Understanding these differences will help us make better decisions and ensure optimal performance for any electronic system. 

At FS PCBA, we consider all the factors and match your requirements to select your project’s right communication protocol (SPI vs I2C). If you have any confusion, feel free to ask anything related to PCBA. We provide all the PCBA-related services.

FAQs

What is a Protocol Analyzer?

A protocol analyzer is a tool for monitoring and decoding traffic on a bus, such as SPI or I2C. It helps troubleshoot and analyze data during transmission, ensuring proper device communication. By collecting and displaying data packets, protocol analyzers facilitate troubleshooting communication-related difficulties.

Does Arduino Support SPI vs I2C?

Arduino has built-in libraries for SPI communication (SPI.h), making it easy to interface with SPI devices.

It is commonly used in projects that require fast data transfer, like connecting to high-speed sensors or memory chips.

Arduino also supports I2C communication through the Wire.h library. It connects to low-speed peripherals like temperature sensors, RTCs, and LCDs.

Can I use both SPI and I2C on the same microcontroller?

Yes, many microcontrollers, including Arduino, support both SPI and I2C. This allows you to use them simultaneously for different connecting devices.

What are the main advantages of SPI vs I2C?

SPI is a full-duplex communication system that offers higher data transfer speeds, making it suitable for high-speed and real-time applications.

Can I connect multiple devices on the same SPI bus?

Yes, but each device will need a separate slave select (SS) line from the master. This can sometimes complicate the wiring.

How do I debug communication issues on an I2C bus?

A protocol analyzer is used to capture and analyze the transferred data packets. Then, it checks for correct addressing, ACK/NACK signals, and timing issues.

Get a quote

Related Blogs

All About PCB Controller

Table of Contents PCB Controller PCB controllers are utilized to efficiently manage and control electronic devices. This article will explore the key components, functions, design

Read More »