Ceramic Chip Antenna vs. PCB Antenna

With the advancement of 5G technology, an increasing number of individuals are recognizing the significance of wireless signals. However, given their wireless nature, it raises the question of how these signals are precisely transmitted and received through the air. In reality, the deployment of 5G PCBA featuring integrated antennas has become widespread in base stations. Antennas, as electronic components integrated into PCB, are responsible for both receiving and transmitting wireless signals. In order to enhance wireless signal transmission, designers typically opt for either ceramic chip antennas or PCB antennas. This article by FS Technology will commence by elucidating the fundamental concepts of these two options and subsequently conduct an in-depth comparison, enabling you to effectively navigate the design process.

What is an antenna in a PCB?

A PCB antenna serves as a permanent signal receiving/transmitting element that is integrated into the printed circuit board of a device. It utilizes the conductive traces of the PCB to transmit and receive electromagnetic waves. This specialized component is engineered to emit electromagnetic radiation within a specific frequency range while efficiently absorbing energy. By incorporating this antenna into the PCB, the need for additional antenna components and interfaces is eliminated, resulting in streamlined and portable wireless communication. Here are the key characteristics of these conventional antennas:

  • Customizability: Conventional PCB antennas offer high flexibility, enabling designers to tailor their designs based on diverse application requirements and characteristics. This ensures optimal performance, specifically tailored to meet specific frequency requirements.
  • Broadband Coverage: Communication systems often require devices to operate across multiple frequency bands to adapt to varying spectrum resources and service requirements. PCB antennas excel in providing extensive frequency coverage, making them suitable for applications that demand a wide frequency range.
  • Cost-effectiveness: By integrating antennas into the PCB design, additional components and connectors can be eliminated, reducing the overall cost of the PCBA.
  • Reliability: Being an integral part of the PCB, these antennas are not susceptible to mechanical stress or damage compared to external antennas. 
  • Size Limitations: The size of the antenna is determined by its operating frequency, and downsizing can be challenging, particularly for certain frequency bands. This presents a potential limitation of PCB antennas.
  • Design Complexity: Designing PCB antennas requires a solid understanding of board layout and antenna theory. Simulations and iterative processes may be necessary to maximize performance compared to using pre-designed ceramic chip antennas.

What is a Ceramic Chip Antenna?

Ceramic chip antennas are a specialized type of antenna primarily utilized in the communication industry. In these industries, ensuring the integrity of signal transmission is a paramount objective. Ceramic materials possess a lower dielectric constant, enabling electromagnetic wave resonance within the ceramic material when integrated into circuit boards, facilitating the broadcasting and reception of information. The following are notable characteristics of ceramic chip antennas:

  • Compact Size: This attribute proves advantageous for mobile communication devices such as smartphones, where antenna integration is essential for wireless communication functions. The small size of ceramic chip antennas enables swift and efficient integration into compact devices, aligning with the prevailing trends of rapid turnaround and miniaturization.
  • Superior Performance: Ceramic chip antennas operate within specific frequency bands. Leveraging the favorable dielectric and conductive properties of ceramic materials, they exhibit excellent performance in terms of gain and radiation efficiency. Furthermore, the sophisticated production process and optimized design contribute to high signal quality, minimizing noise and interference.
  • Seamless Integration: Ceramic chip antennas can be directly mounted onto the Printed Circuit Board using SMT assembly. This automated process streamlines production, particularly for high-volume projects, simplifying the manufacturing workflow.
  • Elevated Cost: As with any ceramic component in electronics, ceramic chip antennas can be expensive. The cost is primarily influenced by material and manufacturing expenses, whether it pertains to the ceramic chip antenna itself or the associated ceramic PCB.
  • Narrow Bandwidth: As previously mentioned, ceramic chip antennas operate within specific frequency ranges. Consequently, designers must develop distinct antenna designs for different frequency bands.
  • Vulnerability to Interference: Antennas are particularly susceptible to interference, and ceramic chip antennas are no exception. The material properties, size constraints, and radiation efficiency of these antennas make them prone to environmental influences, even without external interference from structures. Changes in the layout and physical structure of metals, circuit boards, and other electronic components can affect signal reception.

Ceramic Chip Antenna vs. PCB Antenna

CharacteristicCeramic Chip AntennaPCB Antenna
Size and ShapeRenowned for its compact and diminutive form factor, it boasts a significantly smaller profile, rendering it an optimal choice for devices that prioritize sleek and space-efficient designs, especially in scenarios where space is at a premium.Traditional PCB antenna offers an extensive array of design possibilities. Although it may occupy a larger physical footprint compared to ceramic chip antennas, its flexibility in terms of form factors allows for greater customization options.
Installation and IntegrationThe ceramic chip antenna offers a seamless integration into the manufacturing process as it is directly surface-mounted on the circuit board through automated equipment.Designing PCB antennas that are printed directly onto the PCB necessitates meticulous design considerations.
Frequency RangeOwing to their compact size, ceramic chip antennas are well-suited for short-range communication applications where a smaller coverage area is sufficient.Conversely, PCB antennas, with their larger size and enhanced design, exhibit an extended range capability, making them suitable for long-distance communication requirements and applications that demand wide coverage.
Performance and Signal QualityCeramic chip antennas are notably efficient in terms of gain and radiation efficiency, thanks to their high-quality ceramic material and meticulous construction.While traditional materials may not match the signal performance of ceramics, they can still deliver dependable signal quality when meticulously planned and executed.
Signal InterferenceCeramic antennas are susceptible to potential interference from nearby objects and buildings. Additionally, their close proximity to other electronic components on the board can lead to signal attenuation or blockage in certain cases.Although PCB antennas are also vulnerable to interference, they can be skillfully constructed and strategically positioned on the board to minimize the impact of external influences and ensure precise signal reception.
CostDespite the higher cost of individual antennas, the integration process for PCBA is simplified, resulting in overall lower project costs.The intricate design complexity of traditional antennas often contributes to higher production expenses. However, by integrating the antenna directly into the circuit board, the need for additional components and connectors is eliminated, reducing costs associated with extra parts.
Application Smartphones and tablets, Automotive electronics, Wearable devices, IoT devices, Medical devices Wi-Fi, Bluetooth-enabled devices, Wireless routers, access points, Remote control systems, Industrial automation systems

Ceramic Circuit Material Blog

Alumina Substrate PCB

Alumina Substrate PCB As an essential component of electronic products, printed circuit boards play a crucial role, necessitating the adjustment of substrate materials to cater

Read More »

We'd love to hear from you